Tuesday, May 5, 2026

Top Chef 5/4/26--"The Ultimate Dinner Party" summary

 

Previously on “Top Chef”: we started Restaurant Wars early, as in immediately after the end of the last challenge. Everyone picked teams by sort of standing around and then shuffling into groups. We have Jenn, Oscar, and the twins, and then Anthony, Duyen, Laurence, and Sherry. As the teams came up with menus and concepts and who would do front of house (FOH) or executive chef, Jenn left to go to the hospital, and then stepped out of the competition. Justin was offered the spot, but he declined, to stay with Jenn, so Sieger returned. As we predicted. Oscar's team decided on Latin flavors with a Southern bend, and named themselves Tierra Reina. The other team almost fell for a “global” concept, but Laurence was genre-savvy about it and they went with Carolina comfort food and the name Carolina Queen. Each team had to serve 100 diners, plus judges, plus do takeout. None of the judges sampled the takeout (although they did get reports) and I feel this is bogus. If you make them have takeout, then a judge needs to eat the takeout. Also there was no reason for them to spend an hour immediately making menus, unless it's so they can be there when Sieger returns, because the rest of the timeline seems as usual. Duyen and Carolina Queen had an extremely smooth FOH experience, with a welcome drink and a small wait but nothing crazy. They did forget some stuff on takeout but fixed it quickly. Food here was good but Anthony made rice with bernaise sauce and okra so it was stringy. Over at Tierra Reina, we had the classic “the waiters are not writing tickets correctly and food is going to random tables”. Also the judges waited nearly 45 minutes for their first course. Oscar did do a good job at FOH and had the best dish of the night. But Carolina Queen (and Duyen) won. Brandon made one dish, and it was not cooked properly, so he was sent home. (click for more)

Clicky clicky